| Player | Team | Pos | AL Value | NL value | Mixed Value |
| Albert Pujols | LAA | 1B | $ 42 | $ 41 | |
| Roy Halladay | PHI | P | $ 37 | $ 36 | |
| Felix Hernandez | SEA | P | $ 42 | $ 35 | |
| Hanley Ramirez | MIA | SS | $ 30 | $ 35 | |
| Carlos Gonzalez | COL | OF | $ 30 | $ 33 | |
| Ryan Braun | MIL | OF | $ 30 | $ 33 | |
| Troy Tulowitzki | COL | SS | $ 29 | $ 33 | |
| Miguel Cabrera | DET | 1B | $ 27 | $ 33 | |
| Robinson Cano | NYY | 2B | $ 34 | $ 32 | |
| Carl Crawford | BOS | OF | $ 29 | $ 32 | |
| David Wright | NYM | 3B | $ 36 | $ 31 | |
| Matt Holliday | STL | OF | $ 29 | $ 31 | |
| Joey Votto | CIN | 1B | $ 33 | $ 30 | |
| Nelson Cruz | TEX | OF | $ 27 | $ 29 | |
| Alex Rodriguez | NYY | 3B | $ 31 | $ 28 | |
| Evan Longoria | TB | 3B | $ 31 | $ 28 | |
| Tim Lincecum | SF | P | $ 29 | $ 28 | |
| Dan Uggla | ATL | 2B | $ 28 | $ 28 | |
| CC Sabathia | NYY | P | $ 34 | $ 27 | |
| Vladimir Guerrero | FA | DH | $ 27 | ||
| Joe Mauer | MIN | C | $ 26 | $ 27 | |
| Josh Hamilton | TEX | OF | $ 25 | $ 26 | |
| Ichiro Suzuki | SEA | OF | $ 25 | $ 26 | |
| Josh Johnson | MIA | P | $ 27 | $ 25 | |
| Jayson Werth | WSH | OF | $ 24 | $ 25 | |
| Ryan Zimmerman | WSH | 3B | $ 28 | $ 24 | |
| Ryan Howard | PHI | 1B | $ 28 | $ 24 | |
| Daniel Hudson | AZ | P | $ 25 | $ 24 | |
| Jacoby Ellsbury | BOS | OF | $ 24 | $ 24 | |
| Matt Kemp | LAD | OF | $ 23 | $ 24 | |
| Cliff Lee | PHI | P | $ 25 | $ 23 | |
| Shin-Soo Choo | CLE | OF | $ 23 | $ 23 | |
| Michael Young | TEX | DH/3B/1B | $ 26 | $ 22 | |
| Dustin Pedroia | BOS | 2B | $ 25 | $ 22 | |
| Ubaldo Jimenez | CLE | P | $ 23 | $ 22 | |
| Derek Jeter | NYY | SS | $ 30 | $ 21 | |
| Kevin Youkilis | BOS | 3B | $ 19 | $ 22 | |
| Mark Teixeira | NYY | 1B | $ 19 | $ 22 | |
| Justin Morneau | MIN | 1B | $ 19 | $ 22 | |
| Jon Lester | BOS | P | $ 27 | $ 21 | |
| Prince Fielder | DET | 1B | $ 25 | $ 21 | |
| Chris Carpenter | STL | P | $ 23 | $ 21 | |
| Adrian Gonzalez | BOS | 1B | $ 19 | $ 21 | |
| Mariano Rivera | NYY | P | $ 26 | $ 20 | |
| Brandon Phillips | CIN | 2B | $ 22 | $ 20 | |
| Matt Cain | SF | P | $ 22 | $ 20 | |
| Brian Wilson | SF | P | $ 22 | $ 20 | |
| Hunter Pence | PHI | OF | $ 21 | $ 20 | |
| Bobby Abreu | LAA | DH/OF | $ 21 | $ 20 | |
| Joakim Soria | KC | P | $ 25 | $ 19 | |
| Adrian Beltre | TEX | 3B | $ 23 | $ 19 | |
| Ian Kinsler | TEX | 2B | $ 22 | $ 19 | |
| Tim Hudson | ATL | P | $ 21 | $ 19 | |
| Alex Rios | CHW | OF | $ 21 | $ 19 | |
| Jose Bautista | TOR | OF/3B | $ 20 | $ 19 | |
| Heath Bell | MIA | P | $ 20 | $ 19 | |
| Torii Hunter | LAA | OF | $ 20 | $ 19 | |
| Andrew McCutchen | PIT | OF | $ 20 | $ 19 | |
| Victor Martinez | DET | DH/C | $ 19 | $ 19 | |
| Jose Reyes | MIA | SS | $ 18 | $ 19 | |
| Justin Verlander | DET | P | $ 24 | $ 18 | |
| Jered Weaver | LAA | P | $ 24 | $ 18 | |
| David Price | TB | P | $ 24 | $ 18 | |
| Brian McCann | ATL | C | $ 21 | $ 18 | |
| Aramis Ramirez | MIL | 3B | $ 21 | $ 18 | |
| Andre Ethier | LAD | OF | $ 19 | $ 18 | |
| Shane Victorino | PHI | OF | $ 19 | $ 18 | |
| Justin Upton | AZ | OF | $ 19 | $ 18 | |
| Paul Konerko | CHW | 1B/DH | $ 16 | $ 18 | |
| Alexei Ramirez | CHW | SS | $ 25 | $ 17 | |
| Dan Haren | LAA | P | $ 23 | $ 17 | |
| Andrew Bailey | BOS | P | $ 22 | $ 17 | |
| Clayton Kershaw | LAD | P | $ 19 | $ 17 | |
| Jason Bay | NYM | OF | $ 19 | $ 17 | |
| Zack Greinke | MIL | P | $ 19 | $ 17 | |
| Nick Markakis | BAL | OF | $ 19 | $ 17 | |
| Roy Oswalt | FA | P | $ 17 | ||
| Jonathan Papelbon | PHI | P | $ 21 | $ 16 | |
| Mark Reynolds | BAL | 3B/1B | $ 20 | $ 16 | |
| Casey McGehee | PIT | 3B | $ 19 | $ 16 | |
| Buster Posey | SF | C | $ 19 | $ 16 | |
| Martin Prado | ATL | OF/3B | $ 19 | $ 16 | |
| Grady Sizemore | CLE | OF | $ 19 | $ 16 | |
| Carlos Quentin | SD | OF | $ 18 | $ 16 | |
| Raul Ibanez | FA | OF | $ 16 | ||
| Jason Heyward | ATL | OF | $ 18 | $ 16 | |
| Tommy Hanson | ATL | P | $ 18 | $ 16 | |
| Corey Hart | MIL | OF | $ 17 | $ 16 | |
| Cole Hamels | PHI | P | $ 17 | $ 16 | |
| Rafael Furcal | STL | SS | $ 15 | $ 16 | |
| Adam Dunn | CHW | DH/1B | $ 14 | $ 16 | |
| Joe Nathan | TEX | P | $ 20 | $ 15 | |
| Rajai Davis | TOR | OF | $ 18 | $ 15 | |
| Drew Stubbs | CIN | OF | $ 17 | $ 15 | |
| Jaime Garcia | STL | P | $ 17 | $ 15 | |
| John Axford | MIL | P | $ 17 | $ 15 | |
| Coco Crisp | OAK | OF | $ 17 | $ 15 | |
| David Ortiz | BOS | DH | $ 15 | $ 15 | |
| Johnny Damon | FA | DH | $ 15 | ||
| C.J. Wilson | LAA | P | $ 20 | $ 14 | |
| Brian Roberts | BAL | 2B | $ 18 | $ 14 | |
| Magglio Ordonez | FA | OF/DH | $ 14 | ||
| Juan Pierre | PHI | OF | $ 17 | $ 14 | |
| Vernon Wells | LAA | OF | $ 17 | $ 14 | |
| Austin Jackson | DET | OF | $ 17 | $ 14 | |
| Delmon Young | DET | OF | $ 17 | $ 14 | |
| Carlos Beltran | STL | OF | $ 16 | $ 14 | |
| Madison Bumgarner | SF | P | $ 16 | $ 14 | |
| Francisco Cordero | TOR | P | $ 15 | $ 14 | |
| Derrek Lee | FA | 1B | $ 14 | ||
| Clay Buchholz | BOS | P | $ 19 | $ 13 | |
| Matt Thornton | CHW | P | $ 18 | $ 13 | |
| Kelly Johnson | TOR | 2B | $ 17 | $ 13 | |
| B.J. Upton | TB | OF | $ 16 | $ 13 | |
| Nick Swisher | NYY | OF | $ 16 | $ 13 | |
| Curtis Granderson | NYY | OF | $ 16 | $ 13 | |
| Michael Stanton | MIA | OF | $ 16 | $ 13 | |
| Michael Bourn | ATL | OF | $ 16 | $ 13 | |
| J.A. Happ | HOU | P | $ 15 | $ 13 | |
| Pablo Sandoval | SF | 3B | $ 15 | $ 13 | |
| Chris Coghlan | MIA | OF | $ 15 | $ 13 | |
| Wandy Rodriguez | HOU | P | $ 15 | $ 13 | |
| Ted Lilly | LAD | P | $ 15 | $ 13 | |
| Carlos Lee | HOU | OF/1B | $ 15 | $ 13 | |
| Ryan Dempster | CHC | P | $ 15 | $ 13 | |
| Jorge Posada | FA | DH | $ 13 | ||
| Stephen Drew | AZ | SS | $ 13 | $ 13 | |
| Marco Scutaro | COL | SS | $ 20 | $ 12 | |
| John Danks | CHW | P | $ 17 | $ 12 | |
| Francisco Rodriguez | LAA | P | $ 17 | $ 12 | |
| Tsuyoshi Nishioka | MIN | SS | $ 16 | $ 12 | |
| Chone Figgins | SEA | 3B | $ 16 | $ 12 | |
| Chase Utley | PHI | 2B | $ 16 | $ 12 | |
| Marlon Byrd | CHC | OF | $ 15 | $ 12 | |
| Jose Tabata | PIT | OF | $ 15 | $ 12 | |
| Carlos Marmol | CHC | P | $ 14 | $ 12 | |
| Chad Billingsley | LAD | P | $ 13 | $ 12 | |
| Mat Latos | CIN | P | $ 13 | $ 12 | |
| Billy Butler | KC | DH | $ 12 | $ 12 | |
| Jose Valverde | DET | P | $ 16 | $ 11 | |
| Chris Sale | CHW | P | $ 16 | $ 11 | |
| Brian Duensing | MIN | P | $ 16 | $ 11 | |
| Denard Span | MIN | OF | $ 15 | $ 11 | |
| Neil Walker | PIT | 2B | $ 15 | $ 11 | |
| Adam Jones | BAL | OF | $ 15 | $ 11 | |
| Jay Bruce | CIN | OF | $ 14 | $ 11 | |
| Chris Young | AZ | OF | $ 14 | $ 11 | |
| Ryan Franklin | FA | P | $ 11 | ||
| Chipper Jones | ATL | 3B | $ 13 | $ 11 | |
| Miguel Tejada | FA | 3B/SS | $ 11 | ||
| Jimmy Rollins | PHI | SS | $ 12 | $ 11 | |
| Jason Bartlett | SD | SS | $ 12 | $ 11 | |
| Ian Desmond | WSH | SS | $ 12 | $ 11 | |
| Starlin Castro | CHC | SS | $ 12 | $ 11 | |
| Kila Ka'aihue | OAK | 1B | $ 11 | $ 11 | |
| Elvis Andrus | TEX | SS | $ 18 | $ 10 | |
| Adam LaRoche | WSH | 1B | $ 16 | $ 10 | |
| Aubrey Huff | SF | 1B | $ 16 | $ 10 | |
| Danny Valencia | MIN | 3B | $ 16 | $ 10 | |
| Chris Perez | CLE | P | $ 16 | $ 10 | |
| Brett Gardner | NYY | OF | $ 14 | $ 10 | |
| Ben Zobrist | TB | 2B/OF | $ 14 | $ 10 | |
| Rickie Weeks | MIL | 2B | $ 14 | $ 10 | |
| Michael Morse | WSH | 1B/OF | $ 13 | $ 10 | |
| Ryan Ludwick | CIN | OF | $ 13 | $ 10 | |
| Scott Rolen | CIN | 3B | $ 12 | $ 10 | |
| Huston Street | SD | P | $ 12 | $ 10 | |
| Jonathan Broxton | KC | P | $ 11 | $ 10 | |
| Miguel Olivo | SEA | C | $ 11 | $ 10 | |
| A.J. Pierzynski | CHW | C | $ 11 | $ 10 | |
| R.A. Dickey | NYM | P | $ 11 | $ 10 | |
| Kurt Suzuki | OAK | C | $ 11 | $ 10 | |
| Yovani Gallardo | MIL | P | $ 11 | $ 10 | |
| Brett Anderson | OAK | P | $ 14 | $ 9 | |
| Max Scherzer | DET | P | $ 14 | $ 9 | |
| Neftali Feliz | TEX | P | $ 14 | $ 9 | |
| Colby Lewis | TEX | P | $ 14 | $ 9 | |
| Andres Torres | NYM | OF | $ 13 | $ 9 | |
| Brad Hawpe | TEX | 1B | $ 13 | $ 9 | |
| Alfonso Soriano | CHC | OF | $ 13 | $ 9 | |
| Jeremy Hellickson | TB | P | $ 13 | $ 9 | |
| Manny Ramirez | FA | DH | $ 9 | ||
| Colby Rasmus | TOR | OF | $ 12 | $ 9 | |
| Will Venable | SD | OF | $ 12 | $ 9 | |
| Angel Pagan | SF | OF | $ 12 | $ 9 | |
| Miguel Montero | AZ | C | $ 12 | $ 9 | |
| John Buck | MIA | C | $ 12 | $ 9 | |
| Nate McLouth | PIT | OF | $ 12 | $ 9 | |
| Geovany Soto | CHC | C | $ 12 | $ 9 | |
| Brett Myers | HOU | P | $ 11 | $ 9 | |
| Placido Polanco | PHI | 3B | $ 11 | $ 9 | |
| Travis Wood | CHC | P | $ 11 | $ 9 | |
| Hiroki Kuroda | NYY | P | $ 11 | $ 9 | |
| Carlos Santana | CLE | C/1B | $ 10 | $ 9 | |
| Pedro Alvarez | PIT | 3B | $ 10 | $ 9 | |
| Matt Garza | CHC | P | $ 10 | $ 9 | |
| Jonathan Sanchez | KC | P | $ 10 | $ 9 | |
| Lance Berkman | STL | OF/1B | $ 14 | $ 8 | |
| J.D. Drew | FA | OF | $ 8 | ||
| Howard Kendrick | LAA | 2B/OF | $ 13 | $ 8 | |
| Josh Willingham | MIN | OF/DH | $ 13 | $ 8 | |
| Mike Gonzalez | FA | P | $ 8 | ||
| Jonny Gomes | OAK | OF | $ 12 | $ 8 | |
| Yadier Molina | STL | C | $ 10 | $ 8 | |
| Johan Santana | NYM | P | $ 10 | $ 8 | |
| Jhoulys Chacin | COL | P | $ 10 | $ 8 | |
| Jair Jurrjens | ATL | P | $ 10 | $ 8 | |
| Michael Cuddyer | COL | OF/1B | $ 9 | $ 8 | |
| Francisco Rodriguez | MIL | P | $ 9 | $ 8 | |
| Kendrys Morales | LAA | 1B | $ 9 | $ 8 | |
| Luke Scott | TB | OF | $ 6 | $ 8 | |
| Yunel Escobar | TOR | SS | $ 15 | $ 7 | |
| Erick Aybar | LAA | SS | $ 15 | $ 7 | |
| James Loney | LAD | 1B | $ 14 | $ 7 | |
| Carlos Pena | TB | 1B | $ 14 | $ 7 | |
| Omar Infante | MIA | 2B | $ 12 | $ 7 | |
| Franklin Gutierrez | SEA | OF | $ 12 | $ 7 | |
| Aaron Hill | AZ | 2B | $ 12 | $ 7 | |
| Phil Hughes | NYY | P | $ 12 | $ 7 | |
| Dallas Braden | OAK | P | $ 12 | $ 7 | |
| Trevor Cahill | AZ | P | $ 12 | $ 7 | |
| Julio Borbon | TEX | OF | $ 12 | $ 7 | |
| Seth Smith | OAK | OF | $ 11 | $ 7 | |
| Randy Wells | CHC | P | $ 9 | $ 7 | |
| Ian Stewart | CHC | 3B | $ 9 | $ 7 | |
| Edinson Volquez | SD | P | $ 9 | $ 7 | |
| Bronson Arroyo | CIN | P | $ 9 | $ 7 | |
| Juan Uribe | LAD | 3B | $ 9 | $ 7 | |
| Chris Johnson | HOU | 3B | $ 8 | $ 7 | |
| Adam Lind | TOR | 1B | $ 4 | $ 7 | |
| Asdrubal Cabrera | CLE | SS | $ 13 | $ 6 | |
| Garrett Jones | PIT | OF/1B | $ 12 | $ 6 | |
| Gaby Sanchez | MIA | 1B | $ 12 | $ 6 | |
| Ryan Theriot | SF | SS/2B | $ 11 | $ 6 | |
| David DeJesus | CHC | OF | $ 11 | $ 6 | |
| Cody Ross | BOS | OF | $ 10 | $ 6 | |
| Domonic Brown | PHI | OF | $ 10 | $ 6 | |
| Chris Iannetta | LAA | C | $ 9 | $ 6 | |
| John Jaso | SEA | C | $ 8 | $ 6 | |
| J.J. Putz | AZ | P | $ 8 | $ 6 | |
| Joel Hanrahan | PIT | P | $ 8 | $ 6 | |
| Shaun Marcum | MIL | P | $ 8 | $ 6 | |
| Juan Carlos Oviedo | MIA | P | $ 8 | $ 6 | |
| Russell Martin | NYY | C | $ 8 | $ 6 | |
| Randy Wolf | MIL | P | $ 8 | $ 6 | |
| Carlos Zambrano | MIA | P | $ 8 | $ 6 | |
| Alex Gonzalez | MIL | SS | $ 8 | $ 6 | |
| Drew Storen | WSH | P | $ 7 | $ 6 | |
| Ike Davis | NYM | 1B | $ 12 | $ 5 | |
| Travis Snider | TOR | OF | $ 11 | $ 5 | |
| Ricky Romero | TOR | P | $ 10 | $ 5 | |
| Jake Peavy | CHW | P | $ 10 | $ 5 | |
| Orlando Cabrera | FA | 2B/SS | $ 5 | ||
| Ervin Santana | LAA | P | $ 9 | $ 5 | |
| Carlos Ruiz | PHI | C | $ 8 | $ 5 | |
| Hong-Chih Kuo | FA | P | $ 5 | ||
| Rod Barajas | PIT | C | $ 7 | $ 5 | |
| Brandon Lyon | HOU | P | $ 7 | $ 5 | |
| Mitch Moreland | TEX | 1B/OF | $ 7 | $ 5 | |
| Matt Wieters | BAL | C | $ 7 | $ 5 | |
| Clayton Richard | SD | P | $ 7 | $ 5 | |
| Ryan Hanigan | CIN | C | $ 7 | $ 5 | |
| Alexi Casilla | MIN | 2B/SS | $ 12 | $ 4 | |
| Cliff Pennington | OAK | SS | $ 12 | $ 4 | |
| Gordon Beckham | CHW | 2B | $ 10 | $ 4 | |
| Edwin Encarnacion | TOR | DH/3B/1B | $ 10 | $ 4 | |
| Jason Kubel | AZ | OF/DH | $ 10 | $ 4 | |
| Mark Ellis | LAD | 2B | $ 9 | $ 4 | |
| David Aardsma | SEA | P | $ 9 | $ 4 | |
| Gavin Floyd | CHW | P | $ 9 | $ 4 | |
| Mike Aviles | BOS | 3B/2B | $ 9 | $ 4 | |
| Logan Morrison | MIA | OF | $ 9 | $ 4 | |
| Kyle Farnsworth | TB | P | $ 8 | $ 4 | |
| Jon Garland | FA | P | $ 4 | ||
| Ivan Rodriguez | WSH | C | $ 6 | $ 4 | |
| Nelson Figueroa | TOR | P | $ 6 | $ 4 | |
| Chris Young | FA | P | $ 4 | ||
| Yuniesky Betancourt | KC | SS | $ 6 | $ 4 | |
| Ryan Doumit | MIN | C | $ 6 | $ 4 | |
| Mike Adams | TEX | P | $ 6 | $ 4 | |
| J.P. Arencibia | TOR | C | $ 6 | $ 4 | |
| Anibal Sanchez | MIA | P | $ 6 | $ 4 | |
| Aroldis Chapman | CIN | P | $ 5 | $ 4 | |
| Wilson Betemit | BAL | 3B | $ 10 | $ 3 | |
| Brennan Boesch | DET | OF | $ 9 | $ 3 | |
| Gio Gonzalez | WSH | P | $ 8 | $ 3 | |
| Carlos Gomez | MIL | OF | $ 8 | $ 3 | |
| Orlando Hudson | SD | 2B | $ 8 | $ 3 | |
| Octavio Dotel | DET | P | $ 8 | $ 3 | |
| Joel Pineiro | PHI | P | $ 8 | $ 3 | |
| Hisanori Takahashi | LAA | P | $ 8 | $ 3 | |
| Mark Buehrle | MIA | P | $ 7 | $ 3 | |
| John Lackey | BOS | P | $ 7 | $ 3 | |
| Brandon Webb | FA | P | $ 3 | ||
| Ryan Madson | CIN | P | $ 5 | $ 3 | |
| Derek Lowe | CLE | P | $ 5 | $ 3 | |
| Dillon Gee | NYM | P | $ 5 | $ 3 | |
| Kenley Jansen | LAD | P | $ 5 | $ 3 | |
| Craig Kimbrel | ATL | P | $ 5 | $ 3 | |
| Javier Vazquez | FA | P | $ 3 | ||
| Mike Napoli | TEX | C/1B | $ 5 | $ 3 | |
| Jonny Venters | ATL | P | $ 5 | $ 3 | |
| James McDonald | PIT | P | $ 4 | $ 3 | |
| Brad Lidge | WSH | P | $ 4 | $ 3 | |
| J.J. Hardy | BAL | SS | $ 10 | $ 2 | |
| Shelley Duncan | CLE | OF/DH | $ 8 | $ 2 | |
| Kosuke Fukudome | FA | OF | $ 2 | ||
| Dexter Fowler | COL | OF | $ 7 | $ 2 | |
| Jeff Niemann | TB | P | $ 7 | $ 2 | |
| Scott Baker | MIN | P | $ 7 | $ 2 | |
| Rafael Soriano | NYY | P | $ 7 | $ 2 | |
| Joaquin Benoit | DET | P | $ 6 | $ 2 | |
| Francisco Liriano | MIN | P | $ 6 | $ 2 | |
| Edwin Jackson | WSH | P | $ 6 | $ 2 | |
| Darren O'Day | BAL | P | $ 6 | $ 2 | |
| Wade Davis | TB | P | $ 6 | $ 2 | |
| Ronny Paulino | BAL | C | $ 5 | $ 2 | |
| Yorvit Torrealba | TEX | C | $ 5 | $ 2 | |
| Chris Snyder | HOU | C | $ 4 | $ 2 | |
| Luke Gregerson | SD | P | $ 4 | $ 2 | |
| Ian Kennedy | AZ | P | $ 4 | $ 2 | |
| Tyler Clippard | WSH | P | $ 4 | $ 2 | |
| Barry Enright | AZ | P | $ 4 | $ 2 | |
| David Freese | STL | 3B | $ 3 | $ 2 | |
| Kerry Wood | CHC | P | $ 3 | $ 2 | |
| Lyle Overbay | AZ | 1B | $ 8 | $ 1 | |
| Alberto Callaspo | LAA | 3B | $ 8 | $ 1 | |
| Jeff Francoeur | KC | OF | $ 8 | $ 1 | |
| Jhonny Peralta | DET | SS | $ 8 | $ 1 | |
| Skip Schumaker | STL | 2B/OF | $ 7 | $ 1 | |
| Pat Burrell | FA | OF | $ 1 | ||
| Matt Joyce | TB | OF | $ 7 | $ 1 | |
| Freddy Sanchez | SF | 2B | $ 6 | $ 1 | |
| Darren Oliver | TOR | P | $ 6 | $ 1 | |
| Cameron Maybin | SD | OF | $ 6 | $ 1 | |
| Jeremy Guthrie | BAL | P | $ 5 | $ 1 | |
| Scott Downs | LAA | P | $ 5 | $ 1 | |
| Justin Duchscherer | FA | P | $ 1 | ||
| Tommy Hunter | BAL | P | $ 5 | $ 1 | |
| Daniel Bard | BOS | P | $ 5 | $ 1 | |
| Ronny Cedeno | NYM | SS | $ 4 | $ 1 | |
| Jarrod Saltalamacchia | BOS | C | $ 3 | $ 1 | |
| Jorge De La Rosa | COL | P | $ 3 | $ 1 | |
| Takashi Saito | AZ | P | $ 3 | $ 1 | |
| Ramon Hernandez | COL | C | $ 3 | $ 1 | |
| Josh Thole | NYM | C | $ 3 | $ 1 | |
| Mike Pelfrey | NYM | P | $ 3 | $ 1 | |
| Ricky Nolasco | MIA | P | $ 3 | $ 1 | |
| Chase Headley | SD | 3B | $ 2 | $ 1 | |
| Sergio Romo | SF | P | $ 2 | $ 1 | |
| Casey Blake | COL | 3B | $ 2 | $ 1 | |
| Todd Helton | COL | 1B | $ 7 | $ 0 | |
| Alex Gordon | KC | OF | $ 7 | $ 0 | |
| Don Kelly | DET | OF/3B | $ 7 | $ 0 | |
| Kevin Kouzmanoff | KC | 3B | $ 7 | $ 0 | |
| Ryan Sweeney | BOS | OF | $ 6 | $ 0 | |
| Alcides Escobar | KC | SS | $ 6 | $ 0 | |
| Justin Masterson | CLE | P | $ 5 | $ 0 | |
| Ben Francisco | TOR | OF | $ 5 | $ 0 | |
| Bill Hall | SF | 2B | $ 5 | $ 0 | |
| Milton Bradley | SEA | OF | $ 5 | $ 0 | |
| Jay Gibbons | LAD | OF | $ 5 | $ 0 | |
| Juan L Rivera | LAD | OF/1B | $ 5 | $ 0 | |
| Grant Balfour | OAK | P | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Arthur Rhodes | FA | P | $ 0 | ||
| Carl Pavano | MIN | P | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Mark DeRosa | WSH | 3B | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Brent Morel | CHW | 3B | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Fernando Rodney | TB | P | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Matt Diaz | PIT | OF | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Jason Frasor | TOR | P | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Craig Breslow | AZ | P | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Chris Pettit | LAA | OF | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Gerardo Parra | AZ | OF | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Peter Bourjos | LAA | OF | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Doug Fister | DET | P | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Freddie Freeman | ATL | 1B | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Gregor Blanco | KC | OF | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| David Murphy | TEX | OF | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Blake DeWitt | CHC | OF | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Brad Ziegler | AZ | P | $ 4 | $ 0 | |
| Sergio Santos | TOR | P | $ 3 | $ 0 | |
| Alexi Ogando | TEX | P | $ 3 | $ 0 | |
| Nyjer Morgan | MIL | OF | $ 3 | $ 0 | |
| Jon Jay | STL | OF | $ 3 | $ 0 | |
| Brian Matusz | BAL | P | $ 3 | $ 0 | |
| Sean Rodriguez | TB | SS/2B/3B | $ 3 | $ 0 | |
| Nick Hundley | SD | C | $ 3 | $ 0 | |
| Brandon League | SEA | P | $ 3 | $ 0 | |
| Ryan Raburn | DET | OF/2B | $ 3 | $ 0 | |
| Dan Wheeler | CLE | P | $ 3 | $ 0 | |
| Brandon Inge | DET | 3B | $ 3 | $ 0 | |
| Marcus Thames | FA | OF | $ 0 | ||
| Eric Hinske | ATL | OF | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Brian Fuentes | OAK | P | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Josh Tomlin | CLE | P | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Josh Beckett | BOS | P | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Jason Kendall | FA | C | $ 0 | ||
| Carlos Guillen | SEA | 2B | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Garret Anderson | LAD | OF | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Jason Varitek | FA | C | $ 0 | ||
| Corey Patterson | MIL | OF | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Ramon Castro | FA | C | $ 0 | ||
| Erik Bedard | PIT | P | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Willie Bloomquist | AZ | SS/OF | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Maicer Izturis | LAA | 2B/3B | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Kelly Shoppach | BOS | C | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Michael Wuertz | FA | P | $ 0 | ||
| Tim Stauffer | SD | P | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Jason Vargas | SEA | P | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| James Shields | TB | P | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Evan Meek | PIT | P | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Nick Masset | CIN | P | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Elliot Johnson | TB | SS | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Brandon Morrow | TOR | P | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Sean Marshall | CIN | P | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Johnny Cueto | CIN | P | $ 2 | $ 0 | |
| Jonathan Lucroy | MIL | C | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Reid Brignac | TB | SS | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Tyler Colvin | COL | OF | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Jonathan Herrera | COL | 2B/SS | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Marc Rzepczynski | STL | P | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Everth Cabrera | SD | SS | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Rick Porcello | DET | P | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Brad Bergesen | BAL | P | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Melky Cabrera | SF | OF | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Ryan Spilborghs | CLE | OF | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Matt Capps | MIN | P | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Daric Barton | OAK | 1B | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Shawn Camp | FA | P | $ 0 | ||
| David Ross | ATL | C | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Ty Wigginton | PHI | 3B/1B/OF | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Rich Harden | FA | P | $ 0 | ||
| Rafael Betancourt | CIN | P | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Sean Burnett | WSH | P | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Kevin Gregg | BAL | P | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Clint Barmes | PIT | SS | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Jesse Crain | CHW | P | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Jayson Nix | TOR | 3B | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Brayan Pena | KC | C | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Andruw Jones | NYY | OF | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Cesar Izturis | MIL | SS | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| A.J. Burnett | NYY | P | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Jake Westbrook | STL | P | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Jesus Montero | SEA | DH | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Brandon Belt | SF | OF/1B | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Barry Zito | SF | P | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Jon Rauch | NYM | P | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Jack Wilson | ATL | 2B/SS | $ 1 | $ 0 | |
| Austin Kearns | MIA | OF | $ 1 | $ 0 |